Related by context. All words. (Click for frequent words.) 75 Closing Arguments Set 75 Seeks Delay 75 Judge Nixes 74 Seeks Dismissal 73 Judge Clears Way 73 Feds Probe 73 Judge Throws Out 73 Probe Sought 72 Feds Seek 72 Conviction Upheld 72 Jury Begins Deliberating 72 Jury Seated 72 Ex Aide 72 Judge Halts 72 Supreme Court Hears 72 Aide Pleads Guilty 72 Judge Tosses 72 Judge Hears Arguments 72 Deliberations Continue 72 Jury Deadlocked 72 Jury Hears 72 Jury Deliberating 72 Faces Sentencing 72 Jury Deliberates 72 Lawmakers Seek 71 Judge Denies Request 71 Feds Investigating 71 Panel Hears 71 Panel Rejects 71 Mistrial Declared 71 Awaits Sentencing 71 Man Pleads Innocent 71 Charges Dismissed 71 Jury Weighs 71 Defends Handling 71 Lawyer Pleads Guilty 71 Claims Innocence 71 Judge Sentences 71 Court Tosses 71 Makes Plea Deal 71 Trial Delayed 70 Complicates 70 Judge Refuses 70 Spared Prison 70 Conviction Overturned 70 Closing Arguments Begin 70 Bail Denied 70 Prosecution Rests 70 Aide Arrested 70 Documents Detail 70 Jury Selection Starts 70 Guilty Plea Expected 70 Trial Starts 70 Verdict Reached 70 Lawmaker Calls 70 Court Reinstates 70 Judge Upholds 70 Court Hears Arguments 70 Suspects Indicted 70 Judge Declares Mistrial 70 Hearing Begins 70 Hearing Delayed 70 FBI Probes 70 Lawmaker Wants 70 Guilty Plea Entered 70 Hear Arguments 70 Defense Rests 70 Admits Lying 70 Corruption Trial 70 Witness Testifies 70 Ethics Violations 70 Be Arraigned 69 Supreme Court Hears Arguments 69 Jury Selection Begins 69 Hearing Scheduled 69 Jury Begins Deliberations 69 Witness Describes 69 Supreme Court Upholds 69 Death Penalty Case 69 Tape Released 69 Defends Actions 69 Feds Investigate 69 Testimony Ends 69 Jury Reaches Verdict 69 Prisoner Abuse 69 Enters Guilty Plea 69 Strikes Down 69 Probes Possible 69 Trial Opens 69 Charges Dropped 69 E Mails Show 69 Lawyers Argue 69 Lawmakers React 69 Sentencing Delayed 69 Court Hears 69 Jury Indicts 69 Trial Gets Underway 69 Probe Focuses 69 To Be Arraigned 69 Avoids Jail 69 Remains Mystery 69 Lawmakers Reject 69 Trial Underway 69 Soldier Pleads Guilty 69 Suspect Pleads Guilty 69 Aide Sentenced 69 Ruled Unconstitutional 69 Official Resigns Amid 69 Reaches Plea Deal 69 Faces Arraignment 69 Tapes Reveal 69 Recants 69 Lawmaker Seeks 69 Arraignment Set 69 Woman Convicted 69 Court Clears Way 69 Draws Criticism 69 Businessman Pleads Guilty 69 Strikes Plea Deal 69 Woman Found Guilty 69 Orders Halt 69 Hearing Resumes 69 Phone Jamming 69 Hits Snag 69 Wants Answers 69 Lawyer Asks 69 Seeks Leniency 68 Lawsuit Seeks 68 Mukasey Refuses 68 Official Defends 68 Trial Nears 68 Jury Convicts Man 68 Feds Say 68 Dropped Against 68 Judge Recuses Himself 68 Pleas Guilty 68 Jurors Hear 68 Rejects Plea Deal 68 Rove Testifies 68 Deliberations Begin 68 Dems Seek 68 Can Proceed 68 Wants Probe 68 Raises Concerns Over 68 Feds Indict 68 Hearings Begin 68 Complains About 68 Ruling Expected 68 Rejects Claim 68 Fuels Debate 68 Denies Guilt 68 CIA Leak Probe 68 Deliberations Resume 68 Enters Plea 68 NewsMax.com Wires 68 Mother Speaks Out 68 Suspect Indicted 68 Bush Commutes Libby 68 Panel OKs Subpoenas 68 Admits Role 68 Be Retried 68 Trial Continues 68 Probes Alleged 68 Sidesteps 68 Denies Claim 68 Jury Picked 68 Bribery Case 68 Judge Dismisses 68 Ordered Released 68 Controversy Surrounds 68 Denies Role 68 Resume Deliberations 68 Hold Hearings 68 Defends Role 68 Corruption Probe 68 Plea Deal Reached 68 Sentencing Postponed 68 Agent Testifies 68 Be Dropped Against 68 Alleged Terrorist 68 Faces Scrutiny 68 Implicates 68 Appeal Rejected 68 Seeks Answers 68 Panel Approves 68 Renews Calls 68 Testimony Resumes 68 Guilty Pleas 68 Lawmaker Pleads Guilty 68 Probe Continues 68 Witnesses Testify 68 Rejects Appeal 68 Lawmakers Urge 68 Plea Deal 68 Argues Against 68 Lawyer Wants 68 Waives Right 68 Court Throws Out 68 Doctor Sentenced 68 Jury Convicts 68 Probe Finds 68 Judge Denies 68 Court Reverses 68 Guilty Plea 68 Be Subpoenaed 68 Appeals Court Upholds 68 Testimony Begins 68 Draws Fire 68 Awaits Sentence 68 Official Pleads Guilty 68 Jury Acquits 68 Enter Plea 67 Murder Plot 67 Takes Responsibility 67 Inmate Convicted 67 Verdict Expected 67 Admits Guilt 67 Balloon Boy Parents 67 Victim Speaks 67 Trial Ordered 67 Lawyer Argues 67 Justices Weigh 67 Woman Pleads Innocent 67 Panel Probes 67 Panel Votes 67 Panel Urges 67 Man Admits Role 67 Cop Killing 67 Man Acquitted 67 Takes Plea 67 Raises Questions 67 Aide Accused 67 Announce Resignation 67 Woman Testifies 67 Gets Death Sentence 67 Plead Insanity 67 Draws Scrutiny 67 Lawmaker Says 67 Victim Testifies 67 Deal Reached 67 Causes Controversy 67 Indicts 67 Immigrant Smuggling 67 Suit Filed Over 67 Couple Pleads Guilty 67 Dealt Setback 67 Documents Reveal 67 Police Seek Clues 67 Pleaded Guilty 67 Played Role 67 Inmate Charged 67 Inmate Sentenced 67 Conviction Tossed 67 Stirs Debate 67 Tape Shows 67 Attorney Firings 67 Couple Plead Guilty 67 Nixed 67 Convictions Upheld 67 Judge Overturns 67 Issues Subpoenas 67 Prosecutor Firings 67 Trial Delayed Again 67 Retrial Begins 67 Jury Deliberations Begin 67 Supreme Court Overturns 67 Death Penalty Sought 67 Probe Faults 67 Plea Entered 67 Jurors Deliberate 67 Admits Mistakes 67 Jury Hears Closing Arguments 67 Imperils 67 Ex Cop 67 Dems Criticize 67 Exonerates 67 Politically Motivated 67 Hearing Postponed 67 Execs Plead Guilty 67 Showdown Looms Over 67 Pleads Innocent 67 Ruling Favors 67 Holds Hearing 67 Seeks Reversal 67 Launch Probe Into 67 Lawsuit Challenges 67 Contractor Pleads Guilty 67 Looms Over 67 Home Searched 67 Seeks Probe 67 Report Faults 67 Trial Postponed 67 Resign Amid 67 Charges Filed Against 67 Official Quits 67 Man Gets Probation 67 Guilty Verdict 67 Underscores Need 67 Plead Innocent 67 Torture Case 67 Money Laundering Charges 67 Resentenced 67 Dogfighting Case 67 Avoids Jail Time 67 Prompts Calls 67 Ordered Held 67 Trial Resumes 67 Court Overturns 67 Scrutinizes 67 Lied About 67 Moves Toward 67 Panel Finds 67 Victim Speaks Out 67 Faces Trial 67 Alters Rules 67 Investigating Possible 67 Sniper Suspect 67 Details Emerge About 67 Won'T 67 Deals Blow 67 Suspect Pleads Not 67 Gets Reprieve 67 Causes Stir 67 Hears Testimony 67 Lawmaker Proposes 67 Man Admits 66 Backs Off 66 Alleged Plot 66 Jurors Deliberating 66 Panel Subpoenas 66 Opening Arguments 66 Legal Limbo 66 Feds Arrest 66 Lawmakers Propose 66 Hearing Set 66 Trial Nears End 66 Case Involving 66 Contractor Indicted 66 Assails 66 Justices Reject 66 Rejects Request 66 Accidentally Released 66 Residents React 66 Could Complicate 66 Prison Abuse 66 Jury Selection Continues 66 Locals React 66 Arrest Imminent 66 Trial Adjourned 66 Inmate Accused 66 Jury Selection Underway 66 Spar Over 66 Court Nixes 66 Couple Charged With 66 Alleged Rape 66 Priest Accused 66 Reverses Course 66 Showdown Looms 66 Rejects Bid 66 Loses Bid 66 Orders Probe Into 66 Abuse Case 66 Grand Jury Indicts 66 Businessman Charged 66 Spared Death 66 Gets Prison 66 Terror Ties 66 Convicted Murderer 66 Doctor Pleads Guilty 66 Lawyers Subpoena 66 Jury Resumes Deliberations 66 Finds Possible 66 Rejects Calls 66 Roils 66 Quashed 66 Death Sentence Upheld 66 Tossed Out 66 Subpoenas Issued 66 Lawmaker Pushes 66 Men Plead Guilty 66 Politicians React 66 Aide Indicted 66 Court Upholds Conviction 66 Diocese Settles 66 Denied Bail 66 Violated Rules 66 Scrutinized 66 Conspiracy Charges 66 Witness Tampering 66 Panel Suggests 66 Slay Suspect 66 Remains Elusive 66 Family Reacts 66 Seeks Dismissal Of 66 Seeks Death Penalty 66 Suit Filed 66 Stands Trial 66 Questions Surround 66 Denies Allegations 66 Not Guilty Pleas 66 Compromise Reached 66 Criminal Probe 66 Enter Guilty Plea 66 Panel Weighs 66 Suit Seeks 66 Hearings Continue 66 Lawmaker Apologizes 66 Feds Bust 66 Must Testify 66 Fights Extradition 66 Slaying Suspect 66 Senate Panel Approves 66 Furor Over 66 Withholds 66 Raises Concerns 66 Man Confesses 66 Groups Seek 66 Judge Denies Bail 66 ACLU Sues 66 Trial Begins 66 Terror Suspect Pleads Guilty 66 Scuttles 66 Thrown Out 66 Teen Pleads Guilty 66 Retracts 66 Official Resigns 66 Kills Himself 66 Clears Hurdle 66 Lawyer Quits 66 Draws Ire 66 Nearing End 66 Seek Dismissal 66 Panel Considers 66 Man Executed 66 Could Backfire 66 Jurors Begin Deliberating 66 Defends Himself 66 Suspect Linked 66 Couple Convicted 66 Grand Jury Hears 66 Soldier Acquitted 66 Legislator Wants 66 Hearing Rescheduled 66 Found Innocent 66 Contractor Sentenced 66 Raise Questions 66 Suspects Admit 66 Probe Alleged 66 Wants Charges Dropped 66 Seeks Pardon 66 Jury Spares 65 Gag Order Issued 65 Help Sought 65 Gitmo Detainees 65 Crowds Gather 65 Teenager Sentenced 65 Woman Pleads Guilty 65 Charges Dismissed Against 65 Denies Hiding 65 Judge Tosses Out 65 Acted Alone 65 Pair Accused 65 Report Criticizes 65 Feds Approve 65 Ratchets Up 65 Assassination Plot 65 Gets Maximum Sentence 65 Sentence Upheld 65 Trial Wraps Up 65 Drops Charges 65 Lawsuit Settled 65 Enter Pleas 65 Spark Debate 65 Sparks Controversy 65 Suspect Detained 65 Polygamist Leader 65 Be Probed 65 Sniper Trial 65 Clears Way 65 Abu Ghraib Abuse 65 Leaders React 65 Pushes Back 65 Arrests Suspect 65 Suspects Arraigned 65 Testify Vs 65 Settlement Reached 65 Terror Suspect 65 Caged Kids 65 Deadline Looms 65 Bragged About 65 Court Upholds Sentence 65 Denies Request 65 Invokes 65 Prison Sentence 65 Takes Stand 65 Kidnapping Case 65 Rankles 65 Reignites 65 Sets Deadline 65 Owner Pleads Guilty 65 Expert Testifies 65 Activists Protest 65 Panel Mulls 65 Woman Indicted 65 Shooting Deaths 65 Charges Tossed 65 Raises Questions About 65 Grapples With 65 Panel Upholds 65 Bragged 65 Plead Guilty 65 Under Scrutiny 65 Maintains Innocence 65 Decides Against 65 Doctor Pleads 65 Takes Plea Deal 65 Teen Sniper Suspect 65 Overrules 65 Could Harm 65 Anthrax Hoax 65 Comatose Woman 65 Aide Denies 65 Accused Killer 65 Rebukes 65 Charges Dropped Against 65 Aide Resigns 65 Broke Rules 65 Faces Death Penalty 65 Law Ruled Unconstitutional 65 Testifies Against 65 Prompts Evacuation 65 Appeal Ruling 65 Recuse Himself 65 Anthrax Scare 65 Arrest Warrant Issued 65 Possibly Linked 65 Jury Deadlocks 65 Jury Deliberations 65 Questions Arise Over 65 Being Investigated 65 Draws Protests 65 Standoff Continues 65 Decide Fate 65 Lawmaker Resigns 65 Iraq Rape Slaying 65 Soldier Sentenced 65 Lawyer Seeks 65 Feds Reject 65 Convicted Killer 65 Lawsuit Filed Over 65 Alleged Abuse 65 Derides 65 Turns Deadly 65 Could Undermine 65 Delays Ruling 65 Draws Mixed Reaction 65 Amid Controversy 65 Seeks Tougher 65 Barred From 65 Governor Vetoes 65 Abduction Case 65 Soldier Found Guilty 65 Sex Offender Charged 65 Couple Charged 65 Gets Plea Deal 65 Rebuffs 65 Aide Says 65 Avoids Prison 65 Vote Nears 65 Back Behind Bars 65 Erodes 65 Takes Step Toward 65 Be Extradited 65 Imperil 65 Panel Endorses 65 See Consortiumnews.com s 65 Testify Against 65 Suspects Arrested 65 Fugitive Arrested 65 Suit Alleges 65 Waives Extradition 65 Causes Concern 65 Sentence Reduced 65 Dragging Death 65 Alleged Shooter 65 Considers Extending 65 Faulted 65 Molestation Case 65 Accused Kidnapper 65 Suspect Admits 65 Suspect Held 65 Allegedly Involved 65 Ex Convict 65 Complicate 65 Couple Arrested 65 Plea Deals 65 Faces Uncertain Future 65 Raises Doubts 65 Jury Selection Resumes 65 Jury Mulls 65 Husband Charged 65 Fatal Beating 65 Squabble Over 65 Can Be Avoided 65 Details Emerge 65 Unseal 65 Suspects Linked 65 Accused Murderer 65 Ruling Puts 65 Worse Than Thought 65 Man Arraigned 65 Dismiss Charges 65 Bicker Over 65 Bribe Case 65 Date Set 65 Suspect Faces 65 Man Found Guilty 65 Police Investigate Possible 65 Jury Recommends Death 65 Questions Abound 65 Guilty Verdicts 65 Faces Extradition 65 Spared Death Penalty 65 Seek Delay 65 Accusations Fly 65 Botches 64 Couple Accused 64 Appeal Denied 64 Suspect Wanted 64 Lawsuit Claims 64 Bomb Plot Suspect 64 Mental Exam Ordered 64 Face Retrial 64 Suspect Surrenders 64 Priest Abuse 64 Trade Barbs 64 Iraqi Prisoner Abuse 64 Unravels 64 Priest Pleads Guilty 64 Report Cites 64 Worker Pleads Guilty 64 CIA Tapes 64 Court Upholds 64 Appears Headed 64 Debate Heats Up 64 Visitor Logs 64 Man Charged With 64 Restrictions Eased 64 Gets Probation 64 Woman Sentenced 64 Was Warned 64 Opening Arguments Begin 64 Ring Busted 64 Suspect Appears 64 Kidnap Suspect 64 Spark Controversy 64 Gitmo Detainee 64 Jury Acquits Man 64 Opens Door 64 Accepts Plea Deal 64 Probing Possible 64 Panel Examines 64 Awaits Word 64 Priest Sentenced 64 Woman Pleads 64 Pose Problem 64 Suspect Nabbed 64 Should Resign 64 Raises Doubts About 64 Delays Decision 64 Found Guilty Of 64 Ruled Homicide 64 Admits Mistake 64 Scandal Plagued 64 Offers Truce 64 Murder Trial Begins 64 Seeks Extradition 64 Seek Answers 64 Debate Rages Over 64 Draws Attention 64 Denies Bail 64 Offered Plea Deal 64 Ejects 64 Corruption Charges 64 Pair Sentenced 64 Panel Debates 64 Gonzales Aide 64 Panel Recommends 64 Archdiocese Settles 64 Murder Conviction 64 Killing Husband 64 Nixes 64 Lawmakers Criticize 64 Decision Delayed 64 Manhunt Underway 64 Suspects Appear 64 Warned About 64 Mistakenly Released 64 Priest Admits 64 Raises Fears 64 Seeks Compromise 64 Casts Shadow Over 64 Case Settled 64 Split Verdict 64 Questions Arise 64 Death Prompts 64 Phil Spector Murder Trial 64 Lawmaker Asks 64 Portrays 64 Woman Arraigned 64 House Panel Approves 64 Issues Gag Order 64 Convicted Cop Killer 64 Victims Remembered 64 Petition Seeks 64 Backs Away 64 Fight Looms 64 Juror Dismissed 64 Denied Bond 64 Investigating Alleged 64 Adviser Resigns 64 Sparks Outcry 64 Spills Into 64 Woman Escapes 64 Anthrax Probe 64 Remain Jailed 64 Severely Beaten 64 Awaits Verdict 64 Accepts Responsibility 64 Waives Hearing 64 Investigate Possible 64 Probe Widens 64 Jury Recommends 64 Tapes Released 64 Puts Focus 64 Bush Embraces Pause 64 Lawmaker Urges 64 Candidates Spar Over 64 Fort Hood Shootings 64 Clears Path 64 May Have Fled 64 Dems Push 64 Jury Returns 64 Prompts 64 Murder Suspect Pleads 64 Murder Trial Opens 64 Prompts Warning 64 Derails 64 Hearing Underway 64 Coincides With 64 Drunk Driver Sentenced 64 Wins Reprieve 64 Child Rape 64 Ex Lawmaker 64 Arrests Suspects 64 Tentatively OKs 64 Agreement Reached 64 Woman Faces Charges 64 Panel Backs 64 Court Acquits 64 Suspects Detained 64 Could Affect 64 Aide Charged 64 Hits Roadblock 64 Curtails 64 Bombing Plot 64 Sniper Case 64 Disrupts 64 Fallout Continues 64 Loses Appeal 64 Awaits Ruling 64 Shaken Baby Case 64 Wrangle Over 64 Resigns Amid 64 Poses Challenge 64 Orders Retrial 64 Rape Killing 64 Request Denied 64 Could Hinge 64 Nears End 64 Double Slaying 64 Remembers Victims 64 CIA Leak 64 Should Apologize 64 Throws Out 64 Bedevil 64 Sex Tape Case 64 Case Dismissed 64 Jury Sentences 64 Declared Dead 64 Suspects Held 64 Re Examine 64 Could Threaten 64 Restrains 64 Suspect Confesses 64 Bomb Hoax 64 Probe Targets 64 Denies Charges 64 Murder Suspect Faces 64 Raises Concerns About 64 Death Row Inmates 64 Man Allegedly 64 Denounces 64 Ruled Illegal 64 Denies Abuse 64 Closely Watched 64 Boils Over 64 Suspect Extradited 64 Dispute Leads 64 Who Hid 64 Fraud Case 64 Wife Sentenced 64 Reconsiders 64 Child Sex Assault 64 Reaction Mixed 64 Escalates 64 Arson Case 64 Teen Slaying 64 Testimony Continues 64 Being Readied 64 Renews Push 64 Leak Case 64 Weighs Options 64 Agents Raid 64 Attempts Suicide 64 Case Thrown Out 64 Lawmakers Vow 64 Abramoff Scandal 64 Suspect Arraigned 64 Teens Charged With 64 Could Jeopardize 64 Justices Uphold 64 Murder Confession 64 Bribery Charges 64 Complaint Filed 64 Faces Tough Questions 64 Demands Answers 64 Terror Probe 64 Mall Shooting Suspect 64 Panel Clears 63 Draw Scrutiny 63 Prompts Lawsuit 63 Man Indicted 63 Be Delayed 63 Lawmakers Override 63 Raises Hopes 63 Face Death Penalty 63 Dealt Blow 63 Faces Possible 63 Decry 63 Case Postponed 63 Lawsuit Alleges 63 Defamation Suit 63 Child Porn Case 63 Jury Considers 63 Woman Finds 63 Gun Smuggling 63 Probed 63 Gets Subpoena 63 Files Papers 63 Casts Doubt 63 Law Unconstitutional 63 Mental Exam 63 Controversy Continues Over 63 Winding Down 63 Faces Felony 63 Shifts Focus 63 Quadruple Murder 63 Couple Slaying 63 Child Rapist 63 Charge Dismissed 63 Woman Admits 63 Official Testifies 63 Court Voids 63 Be Prosecuted 63 Dismiss Charges Against 63 Bribery Scheme 63 Alleged Torture 63 Husband Arrested 63 Provokes 63 Mom Charged 63 Lawsuit Targets 63 Admits Killing 63 Causing Trouble 63 Astronaut Charged 63 Plead Not 63 Scandal Hits 63 Shut Down Due 63 Lawmaker Quits 63 Legal Woes 63 Autopsy Finds 63 Renews Call 63 Raises Concern 63 Protest Planned 63 Questions Raised 63 Faces Tough 63 Livid Over 63 Firefighter Accused 63 Man Confesses To 63 Hiring Illegals 63 Court Convicts 63 Cops Seek 63 Nun Slaying 63 Continue Deliberations 63 Makes Plea 63 Elizabeth Smart Kidnapper 63 Ruling Upheld 63 Changes Plea 63 Starvation Case 63 Businessman Sentenced 63 Deals Setback 63 Mystery Surrounds 63 Emotional Testimony 63 Bomb Suspect 63 Sex Assault Case 63 Filed Against 63 Hearings Scheduled 63 Soldier Accused 63 Faces Hurdles 63 Cops Nab 63 Law Upheld 63 Erupts Over 63 Soldier Charged 63 Decision Expected 63 Begin Deliberations 63 Disavows 63 Windshield Death 63 Panel Postpones 63 Tax Evasion Case 63 Suit Settled 63 Racially Charged 63 Lawmaker Charged 63 Raises Eyebrows 63 Dodges Questions 63 Faces Criticism 63 Alleged Killer 63 Suspected Killer 63 Adjourns 63 Suit Filed Against 63 Gay Marriage Trial 63 Soldier Convicted 63 Warrant Issued 63 Son Found Dead 63 Sets Stage 63 Demands Removal 63 Judge Voids 63 Terror Suspects 63 Sees Possible 63 Suit Challenges 63 Struck Down 63 Wrestles With 63 Court Upholds Death Sentence 63 Fatal Bus Crash 63 Lawmaker Sentenced 63 Would Require 63 Focus Shifts 63 Prisoner Abuse Case 63 Deadline Passes 63 Ruffles Feathers 63 Who Fled 63 Debate Continues 63 Files Suit Over 63 Nears Settlement 63 Moves Quickly 63 Likely Caused 63 Suspected Murderer 63 Fraud Probe 63 Seeks Clemency 63 Jackson Accuser 63 Conspired 63 DMX Arrested 63 Gets Suspended Sentence 63 Of Murdering 63 Judge Rejects Request 63 Experts Urge 63 Controversy Continues 63 Interrogation Tactics 63 Could Trigger 63 Attempted Murder Case 63 Indictments Handed Down 63 Child Pornographer 63 Tentatively Approves 63 Allegedly Used 63 Sues Feds 63 Force Evacuations 63 Bomb Threats 63 Welfare Recipients 63 Found Guilty 63 Faces Contempt 63 Erred 63 Questions Linger 63 Seek Clues 63 Face Charges 63 File Lawsuit 63 Considers Ban 63 Settle Suits 63 Formally Charged 63 Alleged Attacker 63 Lawsuit Dismissed