Related by context. Frequent words. (Click for all words.) 50 punitive damages 48 Punitive damages 47 willfulness 46 culpability 45 causation 44 plaintiffs 43 willful infringement 43 Plaintiffs 42 materiality 42 reversible error 42 dispositive 42 proportionality 42 contributory negligence 42 punitive 41 willful 41 offensiveness 41 reasonableness 41 defendant 41 probative value 41 mitigating factors 41 blameworthy 41 Ibid. 41 similarly situated 40 grossly excessive 40 jury verdicts 40 scienter 40 egregious 40 Due Process Clause 40 appellants 40 Appellant argues 40 juries 40 grossly disproportionate 40 compensatory damages 40 Defendant argues 39 appellees 39 patentee 39 noneconomic 39 grossly negligent 39 manifestly excessive 39 exemplary damages 39 prosecutorial discretion 39 tort 39 probative 39 estoppel 39 Tenth Circuit 39 Mutual Automobile 39 aggravating factors 38 quotation omitted 38 damages 38 sua sponte 38 plaintiff 38 Appellants 38 Defendants 38 injunctive 38 appellate courts 38 WCJ 38 prejudgment interest 38 severity 38 aggravating circumstances 38 tort liability 38 Ninth Circuit 38 monetary damages 38 de minimis 37 Fifth Circuit 37 collateral estoppel 37 willful misconduct 37 inequitable conduct 37 subjectively 37 trier 37 res judicata 37 reprehensible 37 fiduciary obligations 37 counterfactual 37 subjective 37 Gen. Stat 37 probabilities 37 appellant 37 totality 36 prejudice 36 Eleventh Circuit 36 dangerousness 36 defendants 36 Minn. Stat 36 spoliation 36 seriousness 36 willful blindness 36 judgment 36 pecuniary 36 mitigating circumstances 36 claimant 36 ripeness 35 dicta 35 negligent misrepresentation 35 newsworthiness 35 5th Circuit 35 construing 35 liability 35 impermissibly 35 jury 35 arbitrators 35 heritability