Comment 010

next comment

Tags: * no editing of reviews after release * for sticky meta/reviews

"- The ARR system now allows reviewers to modify their reviews even after the release of reviews to 
authors. This is very problematic as reviews may be changed without any notice after the authors have 
received them. It is not fair as the committed reviews may be different. I think we should block change 
of reviews after they are released. - The resubmission procedure is very painful, especially for large 
overload cycles like November and January. Resumissions without asking to change reviewers may receive 
completely different reviewer set. This makes the resubmission more random and it is also a waste of 
time to have ~6 different reviewers for one paper. I think the ARR system should be more assured to 
have the same reviewers for resubmission."